See past character quizzes (and winners) in Andi’s Attic >>
Congratulations! Jalaena is the winner of the Macy Character Quiz. She has 48 hours to respond to the email I sent her, or if she sees it here she can let me know in the comments (but I will still need her to email with her mailing address).
Next Month’s Character Quiz: Three-way tie (between comments and emails) between Ellie Coulter, Elizabeth Carter, and Rebecca Carter. So I broke the tie. November’s character quiz (November 16 unless I need to switch it around) is REBECCA CARTER. Don’t ask what the prize it. You can wait and see.
PRIZE
Winner receives a 10″x8″ heavy-duty Andi and Taffy jigsaw puzzle.


I had two dozen entries. For those who like to know, here are the 100% entries (or who missed one but got the bonus answer correct).
- Lizzy D.
- Kate D.
- Sophie T.
- Anaiah B.
- Meena S.
- Hannah F.
- Amanda
- Emma A.
- Genevieve W.
- Abigail F.
- Heather J.
- Heidi J.
- Ruth Anne F.
- Ellie B.
- Jalaena
- Chris R.
Answers to the Macy Walker Quiz
- What is Cory Blake’s first impression of Macy Walker?
- A. He grins and teases Andi about wearing overalls like Macy.
- B. He whispers, “We’re in for a show.”
- C. He sighs and mutters, “Oh boy,” before trying to ignore her.
- How old is Macy at the beginning of Thick as Thieves?
- A. a month from her fourteenth birthday
- B. twelve and a half
- C. barely thirteen
- Who is the first person Macy hits in Thick as Thieves?
- A. Cory Blake
- B. Andi Carter
- C. Jack Goodwin
- What book does Andi give Macy early on in Thick as Thieves?
- A. McGuffey’s reader
- B. the Blue-Backed Speller
- C. Webster’s grammar
- Whose doll does Macy take away?
- A. Sarah’s
- B. Cindy’s
- C. Bethany’s
- What does Macy put under Andi’s saddle?
- A. a nail
- B. a tack
- C. a burr
- In front of which saloon does Andi find Macy?
- A. the Diamond Drink
- B. the Crystal Palace
- C. the Silver Spur
- Which of Macy’s brothers encourages the fight between his sister and Andi after Taffy’s runaway incident?
- A. Ty
- B. Jase
- C. Rudy
- What does Macy say about the letters of the alphabet?
- A. “They look all a jumble when they’re squished together.”
- B. There ain’t no reason for all them things!”
- C. “Why’s anybody want to come up with somethin’ like that?”
- Which of Macy’s brothers does she ignore, and he ignores her?
- A. Ty
- B. Jase
- C. Rudy
- What happened to Macy’s father?
- A. He ran off with another woman after his first wife died.
- B. He was killed in a hunting accident.
- C. He died from an injury from the War Between the States.
- During the night when she stays at the Circle C, Macy sneaks off. Where does she go?
- A. to the kitchen
- B. to the barn
- C. to the colts’ paddock
- What does Macy make Andi promise before she tells her where Shasta and Sunny are?
- A. to never tell anyone
- B. to help her rescue the colts
- C. to have Mitch stand up to Ty
- Macy tells Andi where the colts are. Where are they?
- A. Millerton
- B. Red Valley Creek
- C. Rock Canyon
- What is the Walker brothers’ motto?
- A. “The only good snake is a dead snake.”
- B. “Ain’t nobody gonna fight your battles for ya.”
- C. “If folks can’t look out for their stock, they don’t deserve to keep ‘em.”
- What does Macy suggest her brothers do with Andi after they capture her?
- A. beat her up and leave her in the cabin
- B. hold her for ransom
- C. let her go because she isn’t any use to them
- What does Macy do when Rudy bothers Andi, and after Andi bites his hand?
- A. Macy points a knife at him.
- B. Macy kicks him.
- C. Macy watches silently from safely out of reach.
- Where does Macy take Andi to escape the Walker brothers?
- A. into a corral
- B. into a crack in the canyon wall
- C. into a swampy marsh
- Which brother does Macy threaten to shoot near the end of Thick as Thieves?
- A. Ty
- B. Jase
- C. Rudy
- Where will Macy’s new home be at the end of Thick as Thieves?
- A. with Andi on the Circle C ranch
- B. with her brothers in Nevada as soon as they can get away
- C. in Arkansas with Aunt Hester
Bonus Question. Which horse does Andi give Macy as a thank-you for helping get her colts back? SUNNY

Yay its here!!!
LikeLike
Would you consider doing Peter wilson? Or troy swanson?
LikeLike
I think you should do Rosa garduno!
LikeLike
Hey its cool cause next Tuesday is my birthday and that’s when this ends!! 😀😀
LikeLiked by 2 people
happy early birthday @Lily Johnson!
LikeLike
Thanks!!!
LikeLike
Thanks!!!!
LikeLike
Happy early birthday! How old are you? Two out of my seven siblings have a birthday this month.
LikeLike
She’s 13 and is gonna be 14 🙂
LikeLike
Yay so glad it’s here!!! Hmmm I’ve always wanted an Elizabeth Carter CQ. So that’s my vote. 😁
LikeLike
Kathrine Carter Swanson
LikeLike
Rebeccca or Ellie
LikeLike
Jed Hatton😀
Also, i think Goldtown character quizzes would be really nice
LikeLike
There aren’t enough fans who have read the Goldtown Adventures to make it worth my while to come up with questions for characters. *sigh*
LikeLike
Me and my sister read them they’re my favorite
LikeLike
What about an audiobook for international fans like last quiz?
LikeLike
Yeah?
LikeLike
Well, let’s see if I have an international winner and then she and I can discuss it. 🙂
LikeLike
Katherine carter or Ellie coulter
LikeLike
Aunt Rebecca would be a fun one!
LikeLike
I think a Lucy Hawkins quiz would be interesting 🙂
LikeLike
I like that on the Macy quiz all the answers can be found in one book!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes me too!
LikeLike
Congrats Jalaena!!
Hope you have fun with the puzzle!😊
LikeLike
Lucy Hawkins!
LikeLike
Hey Jenny, how are you and your family doing since the hurricane? Was your house/property badly damaged? I have been praying for you guys!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, good question. How is everything in Florida, Jenny?
LikeLike
Thanks for asking Ruth! Your prayers are appreciated. ❤️ We had no damage to our house and big shed thankfully. But we did have around 15 trees go down. Other than that we are fine! People around us did have major water damage but not us!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thats great Jenny! Glad yall are okay!😊
LikeLike
I think Johnny Wilson or Daniel or Elizabeth Carter would be fun!!
LikeLike
Ellie Coulter Carter and yay!!! 😊
LikeLike
I think the next one should be Aunt Rebecca.
LikeLike
I’m curious Mrs. Marlow why you put paint and brushes on the main picture?
LikeLike
Because it looked cute. 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, it did catch my eye.
LikeLiked by 2 people
LOL, i was thinking the same thing! But it does look nice
LikeLike
Will we find out who on this Isabel’s books on this blog?
LikeLike
Yes. I will update the post tomorrow after the giveaway app randomly chooses the winner.
LikeLiked by 1 person
YAY!
LikeLike
*won the Isabel’s books
LikeLike
Elizabeth!!!!! I really Want her! I think it would be nice to have Elizabeth!!
LikeLike
Kathrine Carter.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Felicity Livingston please😊
LikeLike
Lin Mei
LikeLike
Lin Mei is a good idea!
LikeLike
I think you should definitely do one on Rosa Garduño!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Lin Mei!
LikeLike
Elizabeth Carter!!!
LikeLike
In question 2 the answer is different in the character tab and the book.???
LikeLike
If there is a difference, always, always go with the book. That is the official “truth.” The blog is subject to me being in a hurry sometimes and I can’t remember details. LOL However, I didn’t read anything in the Behind the Scenes on Macy that would have answered #2. The bio on the tab doesn’t mention how old she is when Andi meets her (but I did read fast).
LikeLike
It is the second sentence in the bio. The book has her as older.
LikeLike
I must have been skimming. Lol. I fixed it.
LikeLike
Thanks!
LikeLike
Found all the answers…but one, Q nine!
Going to do more looking!
Thanks for making this, Mrs M!!
Ellie Coulter has my vote!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well… I looked over thee whole book many times and I still can’t find it!
LikeLike
It’s there, word for word, actually. 🤪👀
LikeLike
Okay… I don’t see it though. 😦 lol, I’ll keep looking! 🙂
LikeLike
Found it!! yay! 🙂 🙂 :0
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey Mrs. Marlow! Did you get my answers. I didn’t get a replay when normally you confirm and I’m not seeing it in my sent email files?
LikeLike
No, I don’t see it in my Inbox.
LikeLike
Thanks, I resend it! I’m glad I checked.🤪
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ellie Coulter Carter!
LikeLike
Also Jack Goodwin would be fun!
LikeLike
So far It looks like Ellie Coulter Carter is gonna be next months CQ!
LikeLike
You are only counting the ones you see. Others tell me their choices in their emails. 🤪
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh I see!😜 Can I ask who it will be?
LikeLike
You can find out with the rest of the crew when I post this months winner. 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sent my answers in Mrs M!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sorry Mr.s M! But I can’t find the answer for question 9!🤔😥 could u give me a hint???
LikeLike
Chapter 15
LikeLike
Is it in the beginning of the book??
LikeLike
Thanks!
LikeLike
Could you tell me what chapter question 4 is in
LikeLike
That’s an easy one. Keep reading after Andi talks to Mr. Foster about changing seats.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I just saw this. I am on the road today so sorry! Maybe another fan can give you that information
LikeLiked by 1 person
we cant still send in answers today right?
I had my email all filled out and i never hit send, haha
i understand tho if you cant
LikeLike
Yes you may
LikeLike
Thank you!!
LikeLike
How many entrys have come in so far?
LikeLike
I dunt know for sure. A couple dozen? I’m not home so can’t check
LikeLike
OK!
LikeLike
Oh, OK!!
LikeLike
Wow! A lot of people got the answers correct. Good job everyone! Congratulation Jalaena!
LikeLike
Thank you
LikeLike
I looked at all of them and I only missed one? So did I get any other wrong??
LikeLike
Oh shoot I just saw what happened I put 10. A but in my mind I put the right one B so I guess I got two wrong even though I did not mean too! Oops lol!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think I did the same exact thing so don’t feel bad!🤣🤣
LikeLike
Well At least your gonna do another one!! And hopefully I will win of these times!!!! Thanks for doing them!! 😀😀
LikeLiked by 2 people
Congrats Jalaena!!
Hope you have fun with the puzzle!😊
LikeLiked by 1 person