See past character quizzes (and winners) in Andi’s Attic >>
Congratulations! Jalaena is the winner of the Macy Character Quiz. She has 48 hours to respond to the email I sent her, or if she sees it here she can let me know in the comments (but I will still need her to email with her mailing address).
Next Month’s Character Quiz: Three-way tie (between comments and emails) between Ellie Coulter, Elizabeth Carter, and Rebecca Carter. So I broke the tie. November’s character quiz (November 16 unless I need to switch it around) is REBECCA CARTER. Don’t ask what the prize it. You can wait and see.
PRIZE
Winner receives a 10″x8″ heavy-duty Andi and Taffy jigsaw puzzle.


I had two dozen entries. For those who like to know, here are the 100% entries (or who missed one but got the bonus answer correct).
- Lizzy D.
- Kate D.
- Sophie T.
- Anaiah B.
- Meena S.
- Hannah F.
- Amanda
- Emma A.
- Genevieve W.
- Abigail F.
- Heather J.
- Heidi J.
- Ruth Anne F.
- Ellie B.
- Jalaena
- Chris R.
Answers to the Macy Walker Quiz
- What is Cory Blake’s first impression of Macy Walker?
- A. He grins and teases Andi about wearing overalls like Macy.
- B. He whispers, “We’re in for a show.”
- C. He sighs and mutters, “Oh boy,” before trying to ignore her.
- How old is Macy at the beginning of Thick as Thieves?
- A. a month from her fourteenth birthday
- B. twelve and a half
- C. barely thirteen
- Who is the first person Macy hits in Thick as Thieves?
- A. Cory Blake
- B. Andi Carter
- C. Jack Goodwin
- What book does Andi give Macy early on in Thick as Thieves?
- A. McGuffey’s reader
- B. the Blue-Backed Speller
- C. Webster’s grammar
- Whose doll does Macy take away?
- A. Sarah’s
- B. Cindy’s
- C. Bethany’s
- What does Macy put under Andi’s saddle?
- A. a nail
- B. a tack
- C. a burr
- In front of which saloon does Andi find Macy?
- A. the Diamond Drink
- B. the Crystal Palace
- C. the Silver Spur
- Which of Macy’s brothers encourages the fight between his sister and Andi after Taffy’s runaway incident?
- A. Ty
- B. Jase
- C. Rudy
- What does Macy say about the letters of the alphabet?
- A. “They look all a jumble when they’re squished together.”
- B. There ain’t no reason for all them things!”
- C. “Why’s anybody want to come up with somethin’ like that?”
- Which of Macy’s brothers does she ignore, and he ignores her?
- A. Ty
- B. Jase
- C. Rudy
- What happened to Macy’s father?
- A. He ran off with another woman after his first wife died.
- B. He was killed in a hunting accident.
- C. He died from an injury from the War Between the States.
- During the night when she stays at the Circle C, Macy sneaks off. Where does she go?
- A. to the kitchen
- B. to the barn
- C. to the colts’ paddock
- What does Macy make Andi promise before she tells her where Shasta and Sunny are?
- A. to never tell anyone
- B. to help her rescue the colts
- C. to have Mitch stand up to Ty
- Macy tells Andi where the colts are. Where are they?
- A. Millerton
- B. Red Valley Creek
- C. Rock Canyon
- What is the Walker brothers’ motto?
- A. “The only good snake is a dead snake.”
- B. “Ain’t nobody gonna fight your battles for ya.”
- C. “If folks can’t look out for their stock, they don’t deserve to keep ‘em.”
- What does Macy suggest her brothers do with Andi after they capture her?
- A. beat her up and leave her in the cabin
- B. hold her for ransom
- C. let her go because she isn’t any use to them
- What does Macy do when Rudy bothers Andi, and after Andi bites his hand?
- A. Macy points a knife at him.
- B. Macy kicks him.
- C. Macy watches silently from safely out of reach.
- Where does Macy take Andi to escape the Walker brothers?
- A. into a corral
- B. into a crack in the canyon wall
- C. into a swampy marsh
- Which brother does Macy threaten to shoot near the end of Thick as Thieves?
- A. Ty
- B. Jase
- C. Rudy
- Where will Macy’s new home be at the end of Thick as Thieves?
- A. with Andi on the Circle C ranch
- B. with her brothers in Nevada as soon as they can get away
- C. in Arkansas with Aunt Hester
Bonus Question. Which horse does Andi give Macy as a thank-you for helping get her colts back? SUNNY


Wow Thank you I can’t believe I actually won
I need an email ….
I’m curious why you didn’t enter under the name of Grace.
She probably values her privacy and you can enter under any name you want. I just privately need the real name in order to ship it. 🤪
Just wondering because she uses Grace in the comments.
Check your email because I can’t seen to validate your shipping address. Help!
Congrats Grace!
Good job!
Yay Jalaena!!! Congrats, girl! 😁😁😁
Congrats, Jalaena/Grace!
Congratulations!!!!!!!!❤️
Congrats!!!
Congratulations!!!
Congrats!!! 😃😃😃😃
Congratulations jalaena and.Great job everyone else!!!!!🎊🎊🎊
Congratulations Grace! You did awesome.
It’s a shame I didn’t see this contest. I read the questions and probably could have gotten them all right! Sadly, I heard the next one is about Aunt Rebecca. :(. No offense, but I know NOHING about her LOL!
Oh wow Grace!! Good Job! I hope you like your AMAZING puzzle from Mrs. M
Congratulations Grace! You did awesome.
It’s a shame I didn’t see this contest. I read the questions and probably could have gotten them all right! Sadly, I heard the next one is about Aunt Rebecca. :(. No offense, but I know NOHING about her LOL!
Congrats!!!
Good job!
Wow Thank you I can’t believe I actually won
Liked by 3 people
I need an email ….
Grace
October 19, 2022 at 7:36 am
Wow Thank you I can’t believe I actually won
Liked by 3 people
Reply
Andi Carter
October 19, 2022 at 7:38 am
I need an email ….
Like
Reply
Anonymous
October 19, 2022 at 8:16 am
I’m curious why you didn’t enter under the name of Grace.
Like
Reply
Andi Carter
October 19, 2022 at 8:20 am
She probably values her privacy and you can enter under any name you want. I just privately need the real name in order to ship it. 🤪
Liked by 1 person
Anonymous
October 19, 2022 at 9:07 am
Just wondering because she uses Grace in the comments.
Like
Andi Carter
October 19, 2022 at 10:05 am
Check your email because I can’t seen to validate your shipping address. Help!
Like
Reply
Farmgirl24
October 19, 2022 at 12:24 pm
Congrats Grace!
Liked by 2 people
Reply
LKK
October 19, 2022 at 10:55 am
Good job!
Liked by 2 people
Reply
Emma A
October 19, 2022 at 12:27 pm
Yay Jalaena!!! Congrats, girl! 😁😁😁
Liked by 2 people
Reply
Anonymous
October 19, 2022 at 12:43 pm
Congrats, Jalaena/Grace!
Liked by 2 people
Reply
Faith
October 19, 2022 at 1:58 pm
Congratulations!!!!!!!!❤️
Liked by 2 people
Reply
Anaiah Bruno
October 19, 2022 at 2:07 pm
Congrats!!!
Liked by 2 people
Reply
Lily Johnson
October 19, 2022 at 2:19 pm
Congrats!!! 😃😃😃😃
Liked by 1 person
Reply
Katelyn
October 20, 2022 at 8:57 am
Congratulations jalaena and.Great job everyone else!!!!!🎊🎊🎊
Like
Reply
Lexi W.
October 20, 2022 at 9:15 am
Congratulations Grace! You did awesome.
It’s a shame I didn’t see this contest. I read the questions and probably could have gotten them all right! Sadly, I heard the next one is about Aunt Rebecca. :(. No offense, but I know NOHING about her LOL!
Like
Reply
Anonymous
October 20, 2022 at 1:23 pm
Congratulations Grace! You did awesome.
It’s a shame I didn’t see this contest. I read the questions and probably could have gotten them all right! Sadly, I heard the next one is about Aunt Rebecca. :(. No offense, but I know NOHING about her LOL!
Congrats!!!
Good job!
Wow Thank you I can’t believe I actually won
Liked by 3 people
106 thoughts on “Macy Walker Quiz wow
Yeah, everybody always has something to say. Lol
hey weird question but what MC mean…in the branding post a couple people said it…i looked it up all it said was miscarriage…?
THX
Nobody would think that if they saw it on the rump of a steer or horse in 1800s. Lol
thank you Mrs. M,. yu always find an answer! You are the best
😉🐎👍
Ausome character quiz!!!!!!!
Love this one alot!!
The prizes you offer at character quizzes are really fun, Mrs. M., but for international fans (such as myself) i would prefer an audiobook. 🙂
Well, if you win, I always discuss this with an international entry. It costs me nothing to send an audio book so international winners are always welcome! 🤪
Great, thank you so much!